The point is that you can't predict, when, how badly or even if--to some extent--that a bath done without a full membrane, whether it's a textile or paint on, will fail, and I don't know what the point is of telling someone that just completed a bath in something other than one's approved method is an immediate and complete tearout and start over.
I've seen the opinion that a paint on membrane is completely inadequate and the job should be redone. I've seen people told it's inadequate because they can't see it and really it's been put over the studs underneath, I've seen someone told on the kitchen forum that their backsplash was "Probably not up to Code" because tile shouldn't be installed on drywall, it needed to be installed on cement board, that it should be taken down and redone.
And rarely is it presented in the manner of "In my location, local code requires" or "In my location it's customary to" or "You may want to find out what sort of water proofing your contractor..." it's almost always presented as "Your lowest-estimate incompetent hack-- that it's your fault for hiring, by the way you cheapass--has totally screwed you over by ________etc. and so forth".
Q
Waterproofing behind tile
Q